How to Audit Your SEO Tool Stack and Cut the Overlap

Alejandro Rioja
Alejandro Rioja
3 min read
TL;DR

Most SEO tool spend is overlap: two suites doing keyword research, three tools reporting rankings. List every subscription, map each to one job (queries, crawling, keywords, content, AI visibility), keep the best tool per job, and cancel the duplicates. Google Search Console and a free crawler cover most of what a site under a few hundred pages needs.

Building with AI Agents

Learn how to leverage AI agents for marketing, sales and product. Every week I share what I learned with 5,400+ readers.

The expensive part of an SEO stack is rarely the tool you need. It’s the second and third tool that answer the same question as the first.

People search “seo tools” and land on lists. Nobody tells them what to cancel. This audit takes about 30 minutes and ends with one tool per job.

Step 1: List every subscription

Open your card statements for the last 12 months and your agency’s expense sheet. Write down every SEO-adjacent charge: suites, rank trackers, content optimizers, link tools, browser extensions, anything billed annually that you forgot about. Include the free tools you actually open.

Step 2: Map each tool to one job

Use five jobs. If a tool covers two, note which one you really use it for.

JobThe question it answers
Queries and pagesWhich pages already earn impressions and clicks?
Technical auditWhat’s broken: titles, H1s, redirects, broken links?
Keyword researchWhat should I write next, and who ranks for it?
Content optimizationDoes this page cover what the top results cover?
AI visibilityDo ChatGPT and Perplexity name me for my buyers’ questions?

Step 3: Find the overlap

Any job with two paid tools is a cancellation candidate. The usual offenders:

  1. Two all-in-one suites. Semrush and Ahrefs both do keyword research, competitor gaps and site audits. Pick one.
  2. A rank tracker on top of a suite. The suite already tracks rankings.
  3. A content optimizer you don’t open. Surfer and Clearscope earn their price when someone writes to a brief. If nobody has opened one in 60 days, pause it.

On my own site, Search Console showed my SEO tools list with about 600,000 impressions and 48 clicks in a 28-day window. No paid tool told me that. The free one did.

Step 4: Keep one tool per job and set a review date

Keep the tool your team opens every week. Cancel the other at renewal, not mid-cycle, and put the next review on the calendar 90 days out. If you’re a solo operator or small site, Google Search Console plus the free tier of Screaming Frog (up to 500 URLs) covers the first two jobs at $0. See the free SEO stack by job for the rest.

Step 5: Add the AI visibility check last

Don’t buy a dedicated AI-visibility tool first. Ask ChatGPT and Perplexity your buyers’ top five questions each month and note whether you’re named. Pay for a tracker only when you have clients or a budget that needs the trend line.

The prompt I paste into Claude or ChatGPT

code
Here is a list of my SEO subscriptions with monthly cost and what I use each for.
Group them by job: queries and pages, technical audit, keyword research,
content optimization, AI visibility. For each job with more than one tool,
tell me which to keep, which to cancel, and what I'd lose by cancelling.
Flag any tool whose features you're unsure about so I can check its site.

Check the answer against each vendor’s current pricing page before you cancel. Models guess at plans that changed.

Disclosure: the Semrush, Surfer and Clearscope links are affiliate links. I earn a commission if you buy through them, at no extra cost to you.

Advertisement
Keep reading

Related posts

Keep reading

Get the AI playbook in your inbox

Learn how to leverage AI agents for marketing, sales and product. Every week I share what I learned with 5,400+ readers.

↵ ↵ to see all results esc esc to close